Most likely balls for toes, since they're easier to hide.
Then again, it would hurt like fucking Hell to walk, sooo...
Maybe dicks for fingers, and just wear gloves for the rest of my life.
But there's also the possibility of some freaky bitches being turned on by my weird ass dick-fingers
Would you rather:
Have your penis be in the shape of a banana that needs to be peeled everytime you get down to do some action
or
Have your balls hanging on by a thread that's as thin as your headphone jack