[SatsoffIX534]

Red Dead 2 was a crazy experience to play for the first time, and I still find myself going back to the single-player mode time and time again. It really expanded my appreciation of what story-driven video games could be as a narrative medium. And so naturally the question of whether it is the all-time best arises. The Witcher 3 and Breath of the Wild come to mind as alternatives, but i’m curious to see what other people think.

[Frankclark20]

It’s gotta be close to the top

[BeIeth]

Its pretty epic when you compare it to other open world games

[Ilvcc]

It's certainly up there. The storyline was good. But, after seeing some of the cut content I wish it would have been left in.

[KrappyKroger]

It's second to The Witcher 3 for me, but oh man was it amazing to play.

[Wrangler]

The world is impressive, the story on the other hand is comparable to a piss pore attempt at using a western setting to drive home weak modern morality

[Rex Brooke]

I like the story and the graphics is phenomenal

[PointlessAbsurdity]

it shares the 1st place with witcher 3

[711civ]

Graphics and Gameplay is great. Just didn’t have the time to finish the story

[Slideron Lp]

i havent played rdr2 yet but it seems like people say it is about as good as witcher 3 so its probably up there with one of the greats

[jcreasey123]

The Witcher Series would like to have a word.